
Well I've had the Touch Pro 2 for a week or so now and, despite initial positive impressions, I'm going to have to say that HTC haven't managed to dethrone the Xperia as my favourite smartphone.
Yes it has a better keyboard and yes it does have a larger screen but for my taste there are too many compromises borne of a desire to compete with the iPhone that in the end impact on what Windows Mobile has to offer.
TouchFlo3D is a very nice interface to play with or to show off to your iPhone owning friends - and for people who are looking for an iPhone competitor it does make a good case. It just interferes with the Windows Mobile way of working a little too much for me and also makes the performance a little less snappy than the X1.
The X1's panels are much less intrusive and can either be used extensively or not at all. I have SPB's Mobile Shell panel set as my default but I'll occasionally use one of the other panels as my home screen when conditions dictate. Mobile Shell is probably my favourite application, its fast, very intuitive and manages to work with Windows Mobile rather than against it. I suspect those who have used Windows Mobile for the longest time will prefer the X1's way of doing things to the TP2.
The lack of a 5-way pad on the TP2 isn't a deal breaker, but its presence - along with the excellent optical mouse on the X1 is just a better solution. Other areas where the X1 manages to steal the honours are in the presence of both a headphone jack and camera button, as I've mentioned before.
There are some interface elements which HTC have improved - finger friendly menus and a clone of the iPhone soft keyboard - but a quick search at XDA-Developers will find the same tools for the X1.
In the real world I'd be happy to have either of these as my primary phone, but in the privileged position of being able to choose between them I'll take the X1. At least until WM6.5 arrives for the TP2 this autumn...
Read more...